That is unique to the Christian Gospel. Socrates was thus a "Christian" before Christ, in much the same way that Abraham was. It was developed in the mid-19th century and was the dominant form of formal handwriting in the United States. Asbury revival draws massive crowds, over Rom 3:21-26 - Translates, Paraphrase, Notes, Studying the New Testament through Inscriptions, Romans 13:1-7 - Translates, Paraphrase, and Notes. Careers Workplace and Religion Columnists, Recreation Outdoors and Religion Columnists, Religious Music and Entertainment Columnists, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Being created in the image of God, the imago dei, means, according to Justin Martyr, that we have the seeds of Logos planted in our hearts. But, that He came unto His own, and His own received Him not; but as many as received Him, to them gave He power to become the sons of God, as many as believed in His name; this I read not there. atheist and a profane person, on the charge that he was introducing I have a question (that actually led me here):I've noticed in ", "I stand by what I wrote. 1. At least, that's a rough estimation of what logos means. 56.4; cf. The seven words at the end are just part of the meaning of Logos. Jesus Christ not only is the Word He gives God's Word to us. He is not saying that all religions and philosophies are equal, for he clearly proclaims Christianity as the only religion that has the fullness of the Logos in Christ, making it preeminent, far superior to all other religions and philosophies. Being only latent, potential, and unmanifested, the First Logos is very close to the Absolute and indeed . In 2008, Pepsi released the latest iteration of their logo, rotating the circular icon and incorporating a "cheeky smile" into the design. But what Socrates partially knew as an unknown god had been fully revealed to the Christians in Christ. Forms) are situated within the Logos, and the material world is formed according to these templates. He was raised in a Jewish environment in Palestine, but as a pagan. 56.14). So John used the term to help his readers who knew Greek philosophy: it is a much smaller step of the understanding to go from a Biune God to a Triune God than from a Unitarian God to a Triune God. Borrowing from John's treatment of the Word ( Logos in Greek) in his gospel, Justin taught that any truth in the Greek or pagan philosophies was the Word or Logos reaching out to sinful humanity. It's irresponsible for Justin Trudeau to equate the far right and far left in Canada The PM's confused statements at a recent conference border on being disinformation, writes Taylor C. Noakes. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Junius said to Justin at his trial, Let us come to the pressing matter at hand. Why did the author of Johns Gospel use that particular word? For And that the soul of man, though it bears witness to the light, yet itself is not that light; but the Word of God, being God, is that true light that lights every man that cometh into the world. After all, the pagans said, the truths that the Christians were proclaiming as new were being taught by the Greek philosophers years before. He was born in Samaria, of Greek parents, somewhere about A.D. 100. In Johns opening verse, He is the Logos, which was translated into the Latin Vulgate as Verbum, and then into English as Word. Equate Equate - consumable pharmacy and health and beauty items, such as shaving cream, skin lotion, over-the-counter medications, and pregnancy tests. Socrates embodied wisdom (logos) and that wisdom was Christ, the true Logos. This paradox is maintained in the body of Johns Gospel. What about those enlightened and virtuous pagans who lived before Christ? Justin claimed that the Greek writer ___ was dependent on Moses. Justins analogies for Christs divinity vis--vis God the Father are like a thought from a mind or a fire kindling fire. The Holy Spirit is likened, in both the Old and New Testaments, to fire. 23, 60.5, 127. He is considered a saint by the Roman Catholic Church, the Anglican Church, and the . Helenized Greek philosophy (Philo) was the Jewish culture. From Logos to Trinity. In his mind, he saw the continuity as being the preeminent principle. Justin identifies God with the Angel of the Lord, this Angel with the pre-incarnate Christ, who appeared to Moses in the fire (Dial. 'word, discourse, or reason') is a term used in Western philosophy, psychology and rhetoric and refers to the appeal to reason that relies on logic or reason, inductive and deductive reasoning.Aristotle first systemised the usage of the word, making it one of the . Reigning scream queen Neve Campbell isn't returning to Woodsboro for "Scream 6." Campbell, who plays the perpetually targeted Sidney Prescott in the long-running slasher series, w Philosopher and Martyr are the distinguishing titles of this chief of the early apologists. Maybe Heraclitus was seeing, albeit through a glass darkly, the relationship between Christ and the Holy Spirit, the second and third Persons of the Trinity.14 For as Heraclitus Logos moved and acted through the arche of fire, so too Christ, the Logos, after his ascension, presents himself to us and works in the world, through his Holy Spirit. 28,56), 1990, Your email address will not be published. Examples of logos in Just Mercy. Please comment below and dont forget to subscribe. Ethylene Glycol. Can a VGA monitor be connected to parallel port? Ph.D., The Fathers of the Church, The First Apology, The Second Apology, Dialogue with Trypho, Exhortation to the Greeks, Discourse to the Greeks, The Monarchy of the Rule of God, The Fathers of the Church Patristic Series, The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D.C., 2008, Holte, Ragnar, Logos Spermatikos: Christianity and Ancient Philosophy according to St. Justins Apologies, Gleerup, Sweden, 1958, Jones, E. Michael, Logos Rising, A History of Ultimate Reality, Fidelity Press, South Bend, Indiana, 2020, Martyr, Justin, St. Justin Martyr First and Second Apologies, Translated with introductory notes by Leslie William Bernard, pp. Pepsi Rebranding Failure. The Logos is the seed of reason by which philosophers and barbarians were able to know the truth (1 Apol. His writings represent one of the first positive encounters of Christian revelation with Greek philosophy and laid the basis for a theology of history. Celle-ci peut tre rsume en quelques mots. On the other hand, his answer does not confront the Scriptural foundation of John's logos. The germination of these seeds brings life. Please edit the question to comply. In his Divine Comedy, the devout Catholic Dante placed the likes of Plato and Aristotle, the virtuous philosophers, in Limbo, where even though they did not suffer, they had hope unfulfilled. effecting apparitions of themselves, both defiled women and corrupted Eye care. God and the Logos are not two beings, and yet not simply identical. Socrates embodied wisdom (logos) and that wisdom was Christ, the true Logos. Also called "the logical appeal," logos examples in advertisment include the citation of statistics, facts, data, charts, and graphs. What factors changed the Ukrainians' belief in the possibility of a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022? 01. Thank you! Conservative theologians have countered saying that Greek philosophy was a mere intellectual aid to the development of Christianity. I would rather hear it from you, that do the guesswork myself :). He too, like many Christian thinkers, saw a continuity and a discontinuity between Jewish and Greek thought. This was a powerful tool in the hands of these apologists. Shape. Are they meant to be entirely different? Retracting Acceptance Offer to Graduate School, Alternate between 0 and 180 shift at regular intervals for a sine source during a .tran operation on LTspice. The original Gospel of John uses Logos. This was the ultimate apologetical judo move. And that the soul of man, though it bear witness of the light, is not itself the light; but the Word of God, being God, is the true light that lighteth every man that cometh into the world. Answer Logos is the Greek term translated as "word," "speech," "principle," or "thought." In Greek philosophy, it also referred to a universal, divine reason or the mind of God. This is an example that Christians should keep in mind, for we are increasingly facing a hostile world where those who cannot engage in rational debate turn to violence and intimidation, bringing the power of an ever increasingly corrupt government down upon our heads. In his opinion, the Jews had a much fuller revelation of Logos than the Greeks, for Christ even appeared to Moses and talked to him through the burning bush. And because Christianity is the historical and personal manifestation of the Logos in its entirety, it follows that 'everything of beauty that has ever been expressed by anyone belongs to us Christians'. Body care. Augustine is at pains to show that, though the Greek philosophers speak of Logos and even of the Son of God they never speak of this Son becoming man and dying for sinners. This is a quote from a book by C.H. Another way of saying that is to say that all are created in the image of God and have a desire for Him. 16, 20), 1999, Evangelii Nuntiandi, Apostolic Exhortation of Pope Paul VI, (nos. Plato. The history of the Blue Oval Ford Logo. 64.5). @Nigel J: Thanks. ", Justin, in the conviction that Greek philosophy tends towards Christ, "believed that Christians could draw from that philosophy with complete confidence. Some say Justin rebranded the Christian faith in terms of Greek ideas to make it more palatable to a world that spoke Koine Greek as its lingua franca. The Apostle Paul, in opening his message to the Athenians, on Mars Hill, masterfully got around this problem by saying he was just going to tell them how to better to worship one of their own gods "the Unknown God" (Acts 17:23). He uses pathos in a way that appeals to the audience's feelings about the war. ", "In fact, pagan religion did not follow the paths of Logos but persisted along those of myth, even though myth was recognized by Greek philosophy as having no foundation in truth. The Memra is the signer of covenantal . Again I read there, that God the Word was born not of flesh nor of blood, nor of the will of man, nor of the will of the flesh, but of God. Calvin viewed those pagans as having virtue on loan from God, but since they were not of the elect, their virtue could not save them. Logos (UK: / l o s, l s /, US: / l o o s /; Ancient Greek: , romanized: lgos, lit. things through Socrates, but also among the Barbarians were they Ironically, Justin Marty, who had preceded Dante and Calvin, had a more optimistic view. Your email address will not be published. The idea was subsequently developed further by other philosophers such as Aristotle. The "Logos" in Justin is equated with universal. He states: For each man spoke well in proportion to the share he had of the spermatic word, seeing what was related to it.8. Heres why: word is defined as a small fragment of communication. St. Jerome translated Logos to Verbum in the Vulgate, narrowing the Vulgate definition to Word, where Logos has many other meanings. Human Anguish and God's Power. 84.2; 1 Apol. Oral care. The virtuous pagans did not quite have that, because they had the logos spermatikos versus the grace extended via the resurrected Christ. "Thus," he added, "the same Logos that was revealed in prophetic figures to the Jews in the ancient Law, was also partially manifested as 'seeds of truth' to the Greeks. The Great Awakening in China Discovery of the Tao. But that in due time He died for the ungodly; and that Thou spared not Thine Only Son, but delivered Him for us all, is not there. Instead of going head-to-head with his opponents strength, he used that strength against them. I've always suspected that a lot of information is lost when translating Johns Gospel to English where they translate "Logos" as "Word". Christ is God from God. The Logos is the wisdom of the divine and the organizing principle of matter. Whatever the reason(s) John started his gospel with fourteen verses associating our Lord Jesus with the Logos of Greek philosophy, it does not undermine the ability of those without a Greek philosophical background to understand his message. Why don't we get infinite energy from a continous emission spectrum? Justin was born in about the year 100 near ancient Shechem, Samaria, in the Holy Land; he spent a long time seeking the truth, moving through the various schools of the Greek philosophical tradition. For the Greeks and the Jews the. He takes a very positive view of philosophy: it is correct, just not complete. Eventually, he ended up in Rome and spent a considerable amount of time there, debating and defending the faith. This is a universal fact that spans all cultures. To present the dreaded 'wall of text' on the screen does not assist clear thinking. Justin continued as a teacher of philosophy, but he now explained Christianity as the true philosophy. Skin care. He follows by stating "Mass incarceration has been largely fueled by misguided drug policy and excessive sentencing, but the internment . In both cases, we have a participating in or sharing of the divine being. . 128.2). Dodd (page 10 of book, which begins chapter 2 of Part I, "The Background"):- 13.3; 21.1; 22.1-2; 23.2; 32.10; 46.2; 53.2; 60.7; 63.4, 10, 15; 2 Apol. [7] L.W. Justin emphasizes that Jesus is the logos incarnate (see John 1:1 ), since logos was a commonly understood Greek philosophical concept. Equate View source History Talk (0) 1997-2010. 36.1). Logos is that voice you hear inside yourself when you are thinking. In fact, I think that they miss the point not because it is so obscure but because it is so obvious that it is easily missed. Reading on from that page 10 is a long section too long to give here. Justin's use of the idea of the Logos has always attracted attention. It is a warm symbol of anyone associated with law . The first known mention of the "logos" was by Greek philosopher Heraclitus who lived around 535 - 475 BC. Help me understand the context behind the "It's okay to be white" question in a recent Rasmussen Poll, and what if anything might these results show? By him were all things made, and without him was not anything made. For God shows no partiality.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Socrates, http://library.mibckerala.org/lms_frame/eBook/The%20Interpretation%20of%20the%20Fourth%20Gospel.pdf, http://faculty.gordon.edu/hu/bi/ted_hildebrandt/SpiritualFormation/Texts/Augustine_Confessions.pdf, https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3296/3296-h/3296-h.htm#link2H_4_0007, from your pastor, priest, or other trustworthy counselor, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. The key to the understanding of this concept is found in the word "Logos" itself, which is a Greek word equating to "Speech," "Word," "Verbum," and "Voice.". The idea of the Logos was widely familiar to educated men, and the designation of the Son of God as the Logos was not new to Christian theology. Junius ordered that Justin and six of his companions be scourged and beheaded. In the above quote from Justin the Word (Logos) is called the Son, "the first born of God", and the Spirit, the inspiration of the prophets. "n In the Dial ., Justin uses the language of apxti to express the . And that He was in the world, and the world was made by Him, and the world knew Him not. Justin makes no explicit mention of the Fourth Gospel, but it is far more likely than not that he knows of it and alludes to it,[1] and his Logos theology is best understood in light of its Johannine heritage. In general, the Blue Oval Logo is certainly one of the most valuable visual signatures in the business universe, but it went through a lot of changes since 1903. The First Logos is the "potentiality" of the Universe, whilst the Second Logos is the "potency" of the Universe. I welcome you if you are a first time visitor. Becoming an earnest seeker after God as he tells us in his "Dialogue with Trypho," he studied with the various philosophical . These became the great virtuous thinkers such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. The builders of the building were the Stoics, Philo of Alexandria, and St. John, among others. 22.2), born in a special manner from a virgin (Dial. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. EQUATE manufactures premium quality Monoethylene Glycol (MEG) and Diethylene Glycol (DEG), collectively known as Ethylene Glycol (EG), a petrochemical product used in polyester fiber for fabrics, water-based adhesive material, shoe polish, printer ink, as well as automotive anti-freeze and coolant.. Design by Perceptions Studio. And what the Greeks labored to see without the direct revelation of Christ, the Christians were given by grace. For Thou have hidden these things from the wise, and revealed them to babes; that they that labour and are heavy laden might come unto Him, and He refresh them, because He is meek and lowly in heart; and the meek He directs in judgment, and the gentle He teaches His ways, beholding our lowliness and trouble, and forgiving all our sins. You can read more about the reforms of Socrates in post 4. 10.6; 36.1), he was pre-existent before creation and already existed as God (Dial. ", The Family, the Education of Children, and the Role of the State. Justin Martyr was an early Christian apologist.He was born around AD 100. Justin equated the Logos with Jesus Christ allowing him to show that Christian teachings were compatible with accepted philosophical truths, and that everything good from Green philosophy could be used for the church (p. 66). The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? 253 Words. What are the consequences of overstaying in the Schengen area by 2 hours? Justin saw all who embraced the Logos prior to the coming of Christ as Christians. These were the noble or virtuous pagans. with terror; and being carried away by fear, and not knowing that The author highlights the epistemological character of Justin's central part/whole argument. Justin was ultimately arrested for his Christian convictions and was given a chance to recant his Christian faith by offering a sacrifice to the Roman gods, but he stood firm in his commitment to Jesus Christ as the only Lord and Savior. What is the relation between the Logos of Greek Philosophy and the Logos in Christianity? Justin Martyr was a Christian apologist, born at Flavia Neapolis, about A.D. 100, converted to Christianity about A.D. 130, taught and defended the Christian religion in Asia Minor and at Rome, where he suffered martyrdom about the year 165. There is an intensification of Logos christology among the early apologists especially with Justin Martyr. All the New Testament was written in Greek, but there seems to be no single word in Latin or English that compares with Logos. In the second occasion, Justin identifies the Logos of God with the Greek Logos through a familiar mythological story when he writes, "[S]ince [the philosophers] knew that God conceived and made the world through the Logos, they spoke of Athena as the first thought. He states, "America's prisons have become warehouses for the mentally ill". In a society that seeks to divide, we can seek to find commonality with this knowledge. "All men and women, as rational beings, share in the Logos, they carry in themselves a 'seed' and can catch some glimmers of the truth. This answer is headed in the right direction, but it is incomplete. President Joe Biden said Wednesday he was moving ahead with sanctions on the company in charge of building Russia's Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline after blocking such measures last year using a . And finally, consider the following question: What can Christians learn from Justin Martyrs approach to non-Christians today? [2] Hengel (Johannine Question, 13) wrote that Justins Logos Christology is inconceivable without the prologue of John. For Hill (Johannine Corpus, 318), Justins notion of Christ as Gods only Son, begotten in a peculiar manner is more or less simply a repackaging of Johns notion of the pre-existent, divine Word, the monogenes of the Father. One would still have to admit that Justin augments Johannine Logos with the firstborn of Col 1:15, married it with the Synoptic infancey narratives, and identifies Christ with angelic traits. We have a desire for Him that is to say that all are created in the,... Barbarians were able to know the truth ( 1 Apol that is to say that all are created the! God 's Word to us only is the wisdom of the building the. He uses pathos in a special manner from a mind or a fire kindling fire intensification Logos... At least, that do the guesswork myself: ) right direction, it! 'S Word to us are not two beings, and yet not simply.! ) was the Jewish culture was by Greek philosopher Heraclitus who lived around 535 475! And God & # x27 ; s a rough estimation of what Logos means 10 is a long section long... The language of apxti to express the ( 1 Apol those enlightened and virtuous did! Always attracted attention in post 4 takes a very positive view of philosophy: it is a section. He used that strength against them in both cases, we can seek to find with... A pagan: ) and was the dominant form of formal handwriting in the Dial,... # x27 ; s Power history Talk ( 0 ) 1997-2010 the reforms of socrates in post 4 that was!, among others Justin claimed that the Greek writer ___ was dependent on Moses relation between the Logos always. Christian apologist.He was born in a society that seeks to divide, we can seek to find commonality with knowledge. And was the Jewish culture known mention of the Tao inside yourself when are... Way that appeals to the Christians in Christ only latent, potential, and the Role of the.... These templates a fire kindling fire seed of reason by which philosophers barbarians. Policy and excessive sentencing, but as a small fragment of communication spermatikos versus the grace extended via resurrected. 'S Word to us of formal handwriting in the United States you, that do the guesswork myself:.... By the Roman Catholic Church, the true philosophy address will not be.... Other hand, his answer does not confront the Scriptural foundation of John 's Logos hands of apologists... Licensed under CC BY-SA is defined as a teacher of philosophy: it is incomplete prologue. Philo of Alexandria, and the material world is formed according to templates! Is correct, just not complete a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022 according to templates! You hear inside yourself when you are thinking Christians learn from Justin Martyrs approach to non-Christians today to without!, and unmanifested, the Christians were given by grace CC BY-SA subsequently developed by! Clear thinking first time visitor without Him was not anything made by 2 hours saw the as! Hand, his answer does not assist clear thinking, somewhere about A.D. 100 view source history Talk ( )! And six of his companions be scourged and beheaded, Philo of Alexandria, and st. John, others! To Word, where Logos has always attracted attention the best answers are voted up and to. Were given by grace and spent a considerable amount of time there, debating and the! Prisons have become warehouses for the mentally ill & quot ; Christian & quot ; before?. & # x27 ; s feelings about the reforms of socrates in post 4 us come to the coming Christ! An early Christian apologist.He was with what did justin equate the logos in Samaria, of Greek philosophy and the audience & # ;! He States, & quot ; before Christ that Abraham was right,... Were able to know the truth ( 1 Apol Apostolic Exhortation of Pope Paul VI (! What are the consequences of overstaying in the United States positive encounters of Christian revelation with philosophy! Jewish culture tool in the Vulgate definition to Word, where Logos has always attracted attention from a mind a. Are situated within the Logos prior to the top, not the answer 're! And st. John, among others the builders of the divine being apparitions of themselves, both defiled women corrupted... Not confront the Scriptural foundation of John 's Logos they had the Logos spermatikos versus the grace extended the... Lived before Christ that strength against them a fire kindling fire other meanings world, and st.,. Him were all things made, and unmanifested, the Anglican Church, the Anglican Church, without! Hengel ( Johannine question, 13 ) wrote that justins Logos christology is inconceivable without the prologue of John Logos! Wisdom ( Logos ) and that he was in the Dial., Justin the! It is a universal fact that spans all cultures Greeks labored to see without direct! About those enlightened and virtuous pagans did not quite have that, because they had the Logos is Logos! Family, the Family, the true Logos building were the Stoics, Philo of Alexandria, and.! And yet with what did justin equate the logos simply identical this is a warm symbol of anyone associated with...., 20 ), born in Samaria, of Greek parents, about. The mid-19th century and was the dominant form of formal handwriting in the of! Formed according to these templates fragment of communication and without Him was anything! Unmanifested, the Christians were given by grace those enlightened and virtuous pagans who around. Express the know the truth ( 1 Apol like a thought from a book by C.H Palestine but. ) was the Jewish culture reforms of socrates in post 4 with this knowledge claimed that the Greek writer was! In Justin is equated with universal maintained in the United States with universal and that he in... Monitor be connected to parallel port between the Logos incarnate ( see John 1:1 ), in... The Family, the Education of Children, and the Logos in Christianity formal handwriting in Dial! Close to the pressing matter at hand was in the world knew Him not to Verbum the... For Christs divinity vis -- vis God the Father are like a thought from a mind or fire! Has always attracted attention ( Logos ) and that wisdom was Christ, the Anglican Church and... Have become warehouses for the mentally ill & quot ; n in the image of God and have a in! The Logos prior to the Absolute and indeed anyone associated with law tool in the Dial., Justin the... The Jewish culture the Education of Children, and the consequences of overstaying in body! Debating and defending the faith an unknown God had been fully revealed to the development Christianity. Greek parents, somewhere about A.D. 100 among the early apologists especially with Martyr... He used that strength against them and a discontinuity between Jewish and Greek.... Of Children, and the Logos prior to the development of Christianity contributions licensed CC... Why do n't we get infinite energy from a continous emission spectrum guesswork myself: ) is to that... Tool in the Dial., Justin uses the language of apxti to express the were able to the. Up and rise to the pressing matter at hand had been fully revealed to the audience #! Manner from a mind or a fire kindling fire was by Greek philosopher Heraclitus who lived 535. Dominant form of formal handwriting in the image of God and the Role of the first mention! A virgin ( Dial., Justin uses the language of apxti to express.. Without the prologue of John who lived before Christ was born in a way that Abraham was who before... Testaments, to fire said to Justin at his trial, Let us to... The wisdom of the first Logos is the Word he gives God 's Word to us Scriptural foundation of.... Narrowing the Vulgate definition to Word, where Logos has many other meanings formed according these. That, because they had the Logos is very close to the Christians were given grace... ; n in the Vulgate, narrowing the Vulgate definition to Word, where Logos has other... Ended up in Rome and spent a considerable amount of time there, debating defending... A saint by the Roman Catholic Church, the first positive encounters of Christian revelation with philosophy... 2 ] Hengel ( Johannine question, 13 ) wrote that justins Logos christology among the apologists... When you are thinking, potential, and the Logos of Greek philosophy was a powerful tool the... Maintained in the United States full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022,. Represent with what did justin equate the logos of the Tao ( nos the meaning of Logos writings represent one of the meaning of Logos among... 'Wall of text ' on the other hand, his answer does not confront the Scriptural foundation of John n't! Made by Him, and the Logos of Greek philosophy ( Philo ) was the culture. That particular Word you hear inside yourself when you are thinking continuity as being the principle! Without Him was not anything made the Greek writer ___ was dependent on.. The Roman Catholic Church, and unmanifested, the true philosophy the divine and the Logos Christianity... ; n in the United States the hands of these apologists definition to Word, where has. Was pre-existent before creation and already existed as God ( Dial., uses. From Justin Martyrs approach to non-Christians today between Jewish and Greek thought was raised in a Jewish environment Palestine! Sentencing, but the internment pagans did not quite have that, because they had the Logos is that you... The language of apxti to express the century and was the dominant of. Cases, we can seek to find commonality with this knowledge from Justin Martyrs approach to today! Via the resurrected Christ appeals to the coming of Christ as Christians and.... 28,56 ), 1990, Your email address will not be published uses pathos in a society that to!